7 R29ers, 4 Eye Colours: Burgundy Mascara Is…Different

We’re simple creatures at Refinery29 HQ. Mention Charlotte Tilbury and we’ll be there, eager to try whatever new taste of Hollywood glitz and glamour the makeup artist is serving up. Most recently it’s the brand’s Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! Mascara, $48, in shade Dream Pop that is once-again trending online. Though it was launched in 2022, beauty enthusiasts still can't get over Charlotte Tilbury’s Push Up Lashes! thickening formula in the unusual shade, not to mention the brand’s distinctive paddle-shaped brush.

Of course, though, when it comes to mascara, nothing divides opinion like the curl and hold of a lash. So to find out whether the burgundy iteration of Push Up Lashes! is worth the hype, we road-tested it on seven members of the team, comparing the brush, the formula and the colour payoff on various eye shades. Read on for our honest thoughts.